Today is Veterans Day as well as the anniversary of the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, the solemn landmark at Arlington National Cemetery honoring military personnel killed in action who have never been identified. Since 1999, a vacant crypt on the grounds has honored missing service members from the Vietnam War. The quiz below, from the Ashbrook Center at Ashland University in Ohio, provides an opportunity for you to test your knowledge of Veterans Day and the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier. Continue reading
Category Archives: Musings
The Living Waters
While we celebrate the dedication of the “mother church” of Western Christianity today, I think the image of the prophet Ezekiel goes to the heart of the matter. An Angel of the Lord comes to Ezekiel and describes to the prophet a temple from which rivers of living waters flow to all the corners of the earth. Everywhere the river flows there is not just life, but abundant life – urbis et orbis – to all the cities and into the world. The living waters turn saltwater to fresh, gives all living creatures the chance to thrive and multiply, and all manner of game, fish, and produce are plentiful.
How can one not think of the living water in terms of the sacraments, especially the Eucharist, which are so life giving? It is true, as it is true of the living waters of the Word of God proclaimed. I wonder if we so easily make the same connection with the People of God. We too, in our best days, are a stream of living water moving out into the world. It is from the heart of the Church in which women and men in every age have gone into the world. Living the faith, gossiping the gospel over the backyard fences, proclaiming it aloud in the public square, doing the works of mercy and compassion because they were – and are – compelled by the love and grace of God – all of it a living Faith.
Maybe if Ezekiel were with us today, the Angel would show the prophet a view from space, with the rivers and waves of this living faith washing over the planet.
When St. Paul writes his letter and describes the Corinthians as God’s building he understands that we are more than these beautiful buildings. It is indeed good to have places like the Lateran Basilica as “mother and head” – and to have our own parish church. But it is God’s grace and the faith of people that make the living waters, that make the Church a living entity composed of you and me, living stones, built upon the foundation of the Apostles with Christ as the cornerstone.
Today we celebrate the Dedication of the Lateran Basilica, if you will, the source of the living water. We are reminded that we here at Sacred Heart are connected and receive the grace of those waters. Even as we are reminded that men and women build basilicas and churches. God builds a holy people for Himself. The fruit of the living waters.
Image credit: Pexels + Canva, CC-BY-SA 3.0
An All Saints Sermon from St. Bernard
Let us make haste to our brethren who are awaiting us
Why should our praise and glorification, or even the celebration of this feast day mean anything to the saints? What do they care about earthly honors when their heavenly Father honors them by fulfilling the faithful promise of the Son? What does our commendation mean to them? The saints have no need of honor from us; neither does our devotion add the slightest thing to what is theirs. Clearly, if we venerate their memory, it serves us, not them. But I tell you, when I think of them, I feel myself inflamed by a tremendous yearning.
Calling the saints to mind inspires, or rather arouses in us, above all else, a longing to enjoy their company, so desirable in itself. We long to share in the citizenship of heaven, to dwell with the spirits of the blessed, to join the assembly of patriarchs, the ranks of the prophets, the council of apostles, the great host of martyrs, the noble company of confessors and the choir of virgins. In short, we long to be united in happiness with all the saints. But our dispositions change. The Church of all the first followers of Christ awaits us, but we do nothing about it. The saints want us to be with them, and we are indifferent. The souls of the just await us, and we ignore them.
Come, brothers, let us at length spur ourselves on. We must rise again with Christ, we must seek the world which is above and set our mind on the things of heaven. Let us long for those who are longing for us, hasten to those who are waiting for us, and ask those who look for our coming to intercede for us. We should not only want to be with the saints, we should also hope to possess their happiness. While we desire to be in their company, we must also earnestly seek to share in their glory. Do not imagine that there is anything harmful in such an ambition as this; there is no danger in setting our hearts on such glory.
When we commemorate the saints we are inflamed with another yearning: that Christ our life may also appear to us as he appeared to them and that we may one day share in his glory. Until then we see him, not as he is, but as he became for our sake. He is our head, crowned, not with glory, but with the thorns of our sins. As members of that head, crowned with thorns, we should be ashamed to live in luxury; his purple robes are a mockery rather than an honor. When Christ comes again, his death shall no longer be proclaimed, and we shall know that we also have died, and that our life is hidden with him. The glorious head of the Church will appear and his glorified members will shine in splendor with him, when he forms this lowly body anew into such glory as belongs to himself, its head.
Therefore, we should aim at attaining this glory with a wholehearted and prudent desire. That we may rightly hope and strive for such blessedness, we must above all seek the prayers of the saints. Thus, what is beyond our own powers to obtain will be granted through their intercession.
Sermo 2: Opera omnia, Edit. Cisterc. 5 [1968], 364-368
Image credit: The Forerunners of Christ with Saints and Martyrs | Fra Angelico | ca. 1423 | The National Gallery, London | PD-US
More on free speech
As noted in the blog’s “About”, “…when I have time and inspiration, I muse on things.” Apparently I had time this morning. And so, I mused about free speech.
Two years ago College Pulse and FIRE (Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression) surveyed 55,000 undergraduates. Nate Silver, commenting on the resulting analysis and report, wrote: “Long story, told short, college students are not very enthusiastic about free speech. Particularly true for progressive/left wing students at elite institutions but also more broadly across all colleges. In general student support for free speech is tepid and [citing the report] ‘A significant minority of students don’t even have much tolerance for controversial speech on positions they presumably agree with…When it comes to controversial speakers, students at non-elite colleges are just as intolerant as their Ivy League counterparts.’” I think the point being is that over the last decade (maybe longer) we have collectively raised a generation that is risk-averse in general. Perhaps they have reason to be. Its has been a tumultuous last 20 years.
In the general population, within and outside of the political sphere, Democrats, Republicans, Independents, and everyone in general has concerns over misinformation and are more supportive of governmental restrictions on misinformation. There are calls for governmental censorship on misinformation although no agreement on the standard and who enforces it. Meanwhile the social media conglomerates push for self-regulation.
In some sectors, there is concern that the United States may be reverting to the statistical mean of free-speech tolerance as seen in other western nations who have a more restrictive understanding of free speech. I think we are all finding out what happens when someone stands up for a controversial, unpopular position. How tolerant are we willing to be of the rights of others to express themselves? Because unless we are willing to do that, as Nate Silver commented: “to defend free speech in a principled, non-hypocritical way — the game theory says it’s just going to be a race to the bottom. And given the increasingly tenuous commitment to it in many corners of American society, free speech is going to lose out.”
Here in the United States, free speech is protected by an absolutist constitutional First Amendment. Not so in, for example, Britain. Their free expression operates under the laws of parliament. There is no First Amendment equivalent, rather the milieu of general freedoms protected via common law and Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), incorporated into UK law through the Human Rights Act 1998. Britain balances those freedoms against the parliamentary sense of what is needed for public order, the control of hate speech, and, in general, defamation laws. In other words, it can and has changed.
Legislation in the UK is highly subjective with standards such as “grossly offensive” or whether the expression is deemed to demonstrate “hostility”. Enforcement by local authorities and adjudication by the courts can be somewhat fluid, seeming to shift with politics, cultural norms, and local discretion. If that all seems to paint the picture of a moving target, I don’t think you are incorrect – at least from the standard of free speech that is just part of the American “DNA.”
Legislation and enforcement can vary within the UK. Scotland’s recent hate-crime laws criminalizes behavior that “stirs up hatred” against protected groups, even within the privacy of one’s own home. As you might expect, as soon as the law was passed the police were inundated with anonymous complaints against public figures, private citizens, and neighbors. Besides being overloaded with such reports, under law, it can lead to the police placing a notation of a non-hate crime incident in the person’s record, even if no crime was committed. Different regional police forces interpret the guidance differently, meaning a controversial blog post or workplace comment might be officially logged in Manchester but dismissed in London.
JK Rowling, author of the Harry Potter series, immediately posted a thread on X detailing various high-profile transgender women, explicitly calling them men, and critiquing the law. At the end of the thread she invited the police to arrest her, writing: “If what I’ve written here qualifies as an offence under the terms of the new act, I look forward to being arrested when I return to the birthplace of the Scottish Enlightenment.”
As you can imagine the police were flooded with complaints which, after a few days, announced they did not consider it a hate crime or even an incident. Was it a realization that it was more a public challenge to the law, purposefully incendiary? Was it the reluctance to engage in what would be a public relations nightmare with a person who had the financial means and access to counter punch? And should they have gone to trial, they’d be facing someone who could afford a stable of lawyers to make the battle protracted and public. Or was it a recognition of a fundamental flaw in the law that the police recognized would keep them from applying resources against real-world violent crime?
All something to think about when someone’s free speech has you grinding your teeth and raising your ire.
What are we to do? Remember and act upon this morning’s first reading: “Brothers and sisters: Be kind to one another, compassionate, forgiving one another as God has forgiven you in Christ. Be imitators of God, as beloved children, and live in love as Christ loved us…” (Eph 4:32 – 5:1)
Free Speech and the First Reading
Here in the United States, free speech is protected by an absolutist constitutional First Amendment. We might find someone’s speech repugnant, etc. and wish it would “go away” but as much as it might rub us the wrong way we acknowledge free speech is a fundamental right unless it crosses the line in the narrow categories of expression that cause direct, immediate harm, illegal acts, or fraud.
In a 1974 Yale Law Journal, law professor William L. Cary popularized an economic and legal concept originally coined by U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis. Cary coined the phrase: “racing to the bottom.” Wikipedia describes the expression’s popular use: “Over the late 20th and early 2011s, the phrase crossed over from academic economics and corporate law into the sociopolitical lexicon. In discussions of public decorum, it applies the same structural logic: a negative feedback loop where competing entities (such as politicians, media outlets, or public figures) realize they can gain short-term attention or advantage by abandoning traditional standards, insulting rivals, and lowering the bar of civility. Because one side lowers their standards, the other feels compelled to match them to stay relevant, driving a collective descent into vulgarity or hostility.”
Not sure of the pathway in the Ohio race for Governor, but the recent ad by the Republican candidate’s campaign seems to have entered the race. One can’t help considering that in the context of this morning’s first reading: “Brothers and sisters: Be kind to one another, compassionate, forgiving one another as God has forgiven you in Christ. Be imitators of God, as beloved children, and live in love as Christ loved us…” (Eph 4:32 – 5:1)
It is always good to check yourself. Are you following St. Paul’s advice, staying on the path of love, or are you straying afield and racing to the bottom.
It’s Enough
In today’s first reading we hear Jesus’ reference to “the sign of Jonah.” I think we have been conditioned to think: “Jonah, three days in the belly of the whale. Jesus, three days in the tomb. Ok, the ‘sign of Jonah’ must be Jesus’ Resurrection.” Maybe. I think it is more than that.
If I said, “Oh, say can you see…” most citizens would recognize those words as the opening verse of the national anthem. But I am not asking a question about your visual acuity. I am asking you to recall the whole story of a nascent nation struggling for its independence. In the same way, I would offer that “the sign of Jonah” is asking us to consider the whole of the story of Jonah – and not just the whale.
The Lord came to Jonah and asked him to be a prophet to the city of Nineveh, capital city of the moral enemy of Israel. Jonah’s response was to run away and attempt to sail to the farthest ends of earth. In short: storm at sea, crew throws Jonah overboard to appease the Lord, whale swallows Jonah, and the whale spews Jonah on the beach. Jonah begrudgingly makes the long journey to Nineveh.
Nineveh was located hundreds of miles from where the whale spewed Jonah on the beach. It is not likely that Jonah’s arrival in Nineveh was heralded by the news that he had spent three days in the belly of the whale. Yet somehow Jonah’s recalcitrant and truncated announcement, essentially, “repent or die” was heeded by everyone from King to people, even the animals.
What was the experience of Jonah in the belly of the whale? All of Chapter 2 is Jonah’s realization that he has sinned against the Lord and because of that is at the point of death. Does Jonah ever repent? He certainly realizes that only God can save him, but I am hard pressed to find where he repents. It seems to me that Jonah relents and gives in to the inevitable rather than death. God wants him to be a prophet to Nineveh and God gets what he wants.
The city of Nineveh witnesses the unlikely prophet of Jonah walking their streets with the basic message repent or die. In Hebrew his entire message is five words and I doubt it is given with either volume or enthusiasm. Jonah is a reluctant prophet at best – as shown in the last chapter of the book where he is sulking because they did repent and the Lord was not going to destroy them.
There were no miracles or great signs, just the prophetic word. It is enough and it is clear that the people of Nineveh repent.
Israel witnesses the unlikely prophet from Galilee – what good ever comes from Galilee, right? They were witness to a whole host of miracles and signs, yet they resist. It is as the Gospel acclamation says: “Even now, says the LORD, return to me with your whole heart for I am gracious and merciful.” (Joel 2:12-13) And yet they resist. They want another sign. Jesus says that at this point they will get what Nineveh received, the unexpected prophet announcing repent or die. The life, death, and ministry of Jesus is that sign. The choice is theirs.
We have the one sign given, Jesus the Christ. We have the Word calling us to turn to the gracious and merciful God. As always it is our choice.
Guardian Angels
Today is the Memorial of the Guardian Angels. I think the majority of us grew up with images, holy cards, and picture books of an angle every and always hovering over our shoulder, standing watch, guarding and ready to act at a moment’s notice to protect from the wiles and ways of the devil. So… are guardian angels just a tale the children are told, a metaphor for the continual care of God, or something to help us sleep better at night safe from nightmares.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church ( para. 336) teaches that each person has a guardian angel assigned to them by God. These angels are spiritual beings who protect and guide us throughout our lives. They help us to grow in holiness and lead us closer to God. Specifically, the Catechism states that “from its beginning until death, human life is surrounded by their watchful care and intercession”. This means that our guardian angels are always with us, watching over us and helping us in our journey of faith. Additionally, the Catechism emphasizes that we can petition our guardian angels for help and guidance, encouraging a personal relationship with them (CCC 336). This acknowledgment of angels, including guardian angels, is rooted in Scripture and tradition, affirming their role as intermediaries between God and humanity.
The most direct biblical text is Jesus’ statement: “See that you do not despise one of these little ones; for I tell you that in heaven their angels always behold the face of my Father who is in heaven. (Matthew 18:10) The expression “their angels” was understood by many Church Fathers as referring to angels entrusted with the care of particular persons.
Other important passages include “For he will give his angels charge of you to guard you in all your ways.” (Psalm 91:11-12) In Acts 12:15 when Peter, miraculously freed from prison, knocks at the door, the disciples say: “It is his angel.” (emphasis added). Might this suggest that first-century Jewish Christians were already familiar with the notion of a personal angel associated with an individual? Additionally, Hebrews 1:14 offers: “Are they not all ministering spirits sent forth to serve, for the sake of those who are to obtain salvation?”
The idea did not emerge in a vacuum. In Second Temple Judaism there was already a developed belief that angels were assigned protective roles. Nations were thought to have angelic patrons (Daniel 10). Individuals were believed by some Jewish traditions to have angelic protectors. The Book of Tobit provides a dramatic example of angelic guidance through the angel Raphael, who accompanies and protects Tobias (Tobit 5-12). While Raphael was not Tobias’ “guardian angel” in the later technical sense, the book strongly illustrates God’s care through angelic mediation.
The early Church Fathers generally accepted the existence of guardian angels. St. Basil the Great wrote: “Beside each believer stands an angel as protector and shepherd leading him to life.” St. Jerome, commenting on Matthew 18:10, remarked: “How great the dignity of souls, since each one has from birth an angel commissioned to guard it.” The debate among the Fathers was usually over the nature and extent of angelic guardianship, not over its existence. By the end of the patristic period, belief in guardian angels was widespread and largely uncontroversial.
St. Thomas Aquinas gave the classic theological explanation, arguing that God’s providence governs creation through secondary causes. Angels, as higher intelligences, participate in God’s care for humanity. In the Summa Theologiae (I, q.113), Aquinas concludes that each person is assigned a guardian angel because of humanity’s vulnerability in the journey toward salvation.
In the past I have been asked what is the Fraciscan perspective on guardian angels. Simply put, we stand with the Church’s teaching and traditions. A different question that could have been asked was about St. Francis’ perspective. To be clear, I know of no place in his writings where he mentions guardian angels, but St. Francis frequently viewed angels less as spiritual “bodyguards” and more as fellow creatures participating in the praise of God. In the Earlier Rule (para. 23), Francis joins “all the angels in heaven” with the whole creation in blessing the Lord. Based on that one might say that the Franciscan emphasis tends to be relational and ecclesial: guardian angels are signs that God does not guide us in isolation but within a network of relationships extending even into the heavenly realm.
Image credit: WordPress AI generated using the text of the post.
VJ Day Remembered
The Passion of John the Baptist
Today the Church celebrates the Passion of St. John the Baptist. This is not simply a martyr’s death or the tragic execution of an important biblical figure. His death marks the completion of his prophetic vocation. From the question posed in Luke’s gospel at his birth: “What, then, will this child be?” – this scene completes a life of fidelity to the truth during which John prepared the way for Christ not only through his preaching and baptism, but ultimately by giving his life. It is a celebration with several layers.
John dies as a prophet. The immediate reason for John’s imprisonment and death is striking. He isn’t executed because he proclaimed Jesus as Messiah. He is imprisoned because he tells Herod Antipas: “It is not lawful for you to have your brother’s wife.” (Mk 6:18). John refuses to adjust God’s truth to accommodate the powerful. That places him squarely in the tradition of Israel’s prophets. Elijah confronted Ahab. Nathan confronted David. Jeremiah confronted kings and religious leaders. John does the same and pays the price often associated with prophetic fidelity. At this layer, the feast celebrates the cost of speaking truth when truth is inconvenient.
John prepares the way for Jesus even in death. There is also a remarkable parallel between John’s Passion and Christ’s Passion. Consider that both are innocent and are arrested by political authorities who are reluctant to execute them. Herod recognizes John as righteous; Pilate recognizes Jesus’ innocence. Both rulers nevertheless surrender to pressure rather than doing what they know is right. Both of their deaths reveal the point where God’s Kingdom and worldly powers collide.
John is the herald and forerunner of Christ in preaching, suffering and even in death. His whole life says what he had earlier said about Jesus: “He must increase; I must decrease.” (Jn 3:30) His martyrdom is the final and most radical form of that decreasing.
Why call it the “Passion”? Ordinarily we speak of the martyrdom of saints. The Church traditionally calls August 29 the Passion or Beheading of John the Baptist. “Passion” emphasizes his suffering and deliberately invites comparison with Christ’s Passion. John isn’t another redeemer; Christ alone accomplishes redemption. But John’s death has a distinctive relationship to Christ’s because the entire purpose of John’s life is to point beyond himself toward Jesus.
Still, I am often asked why celebrate such a gruesome event? We are celebrating a most radical example of fidelity. Think of the contrasts: Herod appears powerful. John appears powerless. Herod has the palace, soldiers, wealth, and authority. John is sitting in a prison cell. And yet there is a radical reversal. Herod is actually captive to his reputation, an oath he made is a moment of inebriated passion, the opinion of his guests, and to Herodias. He is captive to his unwillingness to admit that he has made a terrible promise.
John, meanwhile, is physically imprisoned but morally free.
“What, then, will this child be?” (Lk 1:66)
Today’s celebration answers that question. This child will become a man so completely given to God’s call that he will not abandon it even when fidelity costs him his life. He became a faithful witness.
And I think that is ultimately why the Church keeps this rather unsettling feast. John did what he had done throughout his entire life: he pointed toward Christ. At the Jordan he did it with his hand and his voice—“Behold, the Lamb of God.” At Herod’s court he did it by telling the truth. And finally, in prison, he did it by remaining faithful when speaking that truth had become terribly costly.
The Passion of John the Baptist celebrates a life in which the message and the messenger finally became inseparable.
Image credit: St. John the Baptist Rebuking King Herod | Giovanni Fattori, 1856 | Galleria dell’Accademia, Florence | PD-US
Under the fig tree
Today we have a reading from the Gospel of John in which Jesus encounters Nathaniel under a fig tree. It is only at the end of the reading that angels get a mention: “you will see heaven opened and the angels of God ascending and descending on the Son of Man.” (John 1:51) Otherwise, Jesus is involved in the calling of the disciples, having found Peter, Andrew and Philip at work. He finds Nathaniel sitting under a fig tree. Micah 4:3-4 and Zechariah 3:10 suggest that “under a fig tree” may be a place of contemplation. It may be that Nathanael was a “thinker”. He wouldn’t accept anything at face value, but he would question and contemplate everything until he was sure of its truthfulness. On the other hand, sitting in the shade, eating the free figs, might indicate that he was just a lazy bum.
I think that we need more fig trees — at least in a figurative sense. They can be quite messy when the unpicked, over-ripe fruit falls to the ground and attracts all kinds of birds and bugs. What I mean is that we need more places and time to be contemplative — time to be quiet and think. We need more “fig trees” in church — places and times to stop working, to stop doing the business, and to sit and reflect. Perhaps we might become more Christian with less busyness in our own lives and more time to ask the simple question to ourselves: how was I a disciple of Christ.
Perhaps we would be a better church if we could stop and contemplate our place in this world we are called to evangelize. We might find things quite messy: unpicked, over-ripe fruit on the ground. A harvest wasted.
In my last assignment, the Franciscans had just taken up pastoral leadership of a parish almost 150 years old. There was a lot of focus on the past, a church caught in the Newtonian mechanics of an object at rest. We can learn from the past, but we also have to consider the now, and then contemplate a new future of a church not at rest, but a restless church.
Same is true of each one of us as individuals, members of a family, and all the other roles we have in life.
Where is your fig tree? Find it and may the messengers of God, the angels, bring you divine food for thought.
Nathaniel under the fig tree | James Tissot, ca. 1890 | Brooklyn Museum | PD
