The First Two Servants

This coming Sunday is the 33rd Sunday in Ordinary Time. Our gospel is the Parable of the Talents: Immediately 16 the one who received five talents went and traded with them, and made another five. 17 Likewise, the one who received two made another two. 18 But the man who received one went off and dug a hole in the ground and buried his master’s money. 19 After a long time the master of those servants came back and settled accounts with them.

The first servant eagerness is a model for enthusiastic discipleship. He and his first colleague achieved spectacular results (100% profit), but clearly there was a risk involved, which their other coworker was unwilling to face. No doubt he would have justified his action as prudent rather than lazy (his master’s term for it, v. 26), but his prudence results in no benefit to his master.  Of course there is some benefit to simply maintaining the status quo. A contemporary rabbinic axiom was “Money can only be kept safe by placing it in the earth.” (b. B. Meṣiʿa 42a).

The “long time” in this parable corresponds to the delay in 24:48 and 25:5. There is time for life (and trade) to take its normal course. What exact course is taken depends on the servant. The settling of accounts immediately on the master’s return indicates what the opening scene has not made explicit: that the master was expecting his money to have been put to good use in the interval.

20 The one who had received five talents came forward bringing the additional five. He said, ‘Master, you gave me five talents. See, I have made five more.’ 21 His master said to him, ‘Well done, my good and faithful servant. Since you were faithful in small matters, I will give you great responsibilities. Come, share your master’s joy.’ 22 (Then) the one who had received two talents also came forward and said, ‘Master, you gave me two talents. See, I have made two more.’ 23 His master said to him, ‘Well done, my good and faithful servant. Since you were faithful in small matters, I will give you great responsibilities. Come, share your master’s joy.’ 

Note that the master’s response to the first two servants does not depend upon the initial endowment. He welcomes each of them regardless of their abilities, what they were given to begin with, or even the final margin of gain. Consider the workers in the vineyard (20:1–16) where some did not have the opportunity to work as long as others, but all were equally rewarded. These servants are commended, like the servant of 24:45, as “faithful:” they have done what was expected of them. But the reward for reliability, as for the servant in 24:47, is not to be released from responsibility but to be given more of it. You don’t “retire” from being a disciple. If a sum such as five talents is “small matters,” the great things which follow will be a huge responsibility indeed. But along with the added responsibility goes a significant change of status, the new relationship of sharing the master’s joy.

In the story of the Rich Young Man, 19:28 suggests that in the “new age” the reward for faithfulness will be to share the authority of the enthroned Son of Man. Is it reading too much into our parable to envisage heaven as a state not of relaxed pleasure but of active cooperation with the purpose of God as well as enjoyment of his favor?


Image credit: The Parable of the Talents by Willem de Porter, 17th century, National Gallery of Prague, PD-US

A Curious Start

This coming Sunday is the 33rd Sunday in Ordinary Time. Our gospel is the Parable of the Talents.14 “It will be as when a man who was going on a journey called in his servants and entrusted his possessions to them. 15 To one he gave five talents; to another, two; to a third, one—to each according to his ability. Then he went away.”

If Matthew had used a copy editor, I am sure they would be discussing the use of “it.” What will be as…? Curiously, most Matthean parables are explicit when it comes to the kingdom of heaven. The previous parable (Wise and Foolish Maidens) begins, “the kingdom of heaven will be like.” (25:1). Here Matthew begins hōsper gar, literally “for just as”, indicating that the same subject is under discussion.

The setting is similar to that of the sayings about Faithful and Unfaithful Servants (24:45–51), focusing on the responsibility of servants in their master’s absence, but in the parable of Talents the stakes are higher. This is not about domestic management, but about high-level commercial responsibility with an extraordinarily large capital sum to trade with. The principle of different levels of responsibility depending on the servants’ individual ability hints at the parable’s intended application. The kingdom of heaven is not a “one-size-fits-all” economy. Consider the different yields produced by the good seed in 13:8 (Parable of the Sower). God’s people are different, and he treats them differently; “much will be expected of those to whom much has been given” (Luke 12:48) – or “For to everyone who has, more will be given and he will grow rich; but from the one who has not, even what he has will be taken away” (Mt 25:29).  In the Lucan version of this parable the point is made by the different trading results of servants who are given the same initial capital; In Matthew the principle of individuality is built into the initial distribution. It will be the servants’ responsibility not to look with envy at the different hand which has been dealt to their colleagues, but to make the most of what they have, and it will be important to note that the first two servants will receive identical commendations in vv. 21 and 23 even though the sums they have gained differ, since each has succeeded in proportion to his initial endowment.


Image credit: The Parable of the Talents by Willem de Porter, 17th century, National Gallery of Prague, PD-US

Some Different Views

This coming Sunday is the 33rd Sunday in Ordinary Time. Our gospel is the Parable of the Talents. Warren Carter has a different take on the parable. He views the parable as criticism of “the perspective of the wealthy elite” who punishes “the one who subverts the system:”  He writes “On the basis of Jesus’ teaching in 19:16–22 [the Rich Young Man], the master and the first two servants could rightly be rebuked for their greedy and acquisitive actions. The third servant should be commended for not adding to the master’s wealth by not depriving others!” Similarly, Barbara Reid (CBQ 66) notes: “The third servant is the honorable one because he unmasks the wickedness of the master”—though Reid herself mentions this exegesis only as a “possibility” which she does not in fact adopt. 

Bruce Malina and Richard Rohrbaugh (Social-Science Commentary on the Synoptic Gospels) suggest that there was a “limited good” understanding in the first-century Mediterranean world. This is quite a different perspective than our western, 20th century, capitalistic world, where we operated with a sense that goods are in an “unlimited supply.” They write concerning this parable: “Because the pie was “limited” and already distributed, an increase in the share of one person automatically meant a loss for someone else. Honorable people, therefore, did not try to get more, and those who did were automatically considered thieves. Noblemen avoided such accusations of getting rich at the expense of others by having their affairs handled by slaves. Such behavior could be condoned in slaves, since slaves were without honor anyway.” The third servant buried his master’s money to ensure that it remained intact. This, of course, was the honorable thing for a freeman to do; was it honorable behavior for a servant? They have further thoughts on the “limited good” in an earlier section: “An honorable man would thus be interested only in what was rightfully his and would have no desire to gain anything more, that is, to take what was another’s. Acquisition was, by its very nature, understood as stealing. The ancient Mediterranean attitude was that every rich person is either unjust or the heir of an unjust person (Jerome, In Heiremiam 2.5.2). Profit making and the acquisition of wealth were automatically assumed to be the result of extortion or fraud. The notion of an honest rich man was a first-century oxymoron.”

I primarily offer these voices to again point to the nature of parables.  There is much room for interpretation. Still, one can critique Carter and the others since this is not the only parable which assumes the validity of acquiring wealth and of private ownership. Even in the end of our parable of the talents, the two servants acquire a great deal of wealth in private ownership. Yet there is the question of what one does while being ready.

It is perhaps less about the “what” and more about readiness and responsibility. It is not about natural endowment, though the degree of responsibility given to each depends on their individual ability (v. 15). The “talents,” however, do not represent that individual ability but are allocated on the basis of it. They represent not the natural gifts and aptitudes which everyone has, but the specific privileges and opportunities of the kingdom of heaven and the responsibilities they entail. St. Paul notes this same distinction in “gifts.” The parable thus teaches that each disciple has God-given gifts and opportunities to be of service to the Lord, and that these are not the same for everyone, but it is left to the reader to discern just what those gifts and opportunities are. This is appropriate to the open-ended nature of parables, and different readers may rightly place the emphasis on different aspects of their discipleship. What matters is that, however precisely the “talents” are interpreted, each disciple should live and work in such a boldly enterprising way that the returning master will say “Well done, you good, trustworthy slave.”


Image credit: The Parable of the Talents by Willem de Porter, 17th century, National Gallery of Prague, PD-US

The Parable: Matthew and Luke

This coming Sunday is the 33rd Sunday in Ordinary Time. Our gospel is the Parable of the Talents.  It is very easy to conflate the Lukan and Matthean versions of this parable. Below I offer a side by side comparison. Surprisingly, the Lukan version is not a Sunday Gospel, not even in Lectionary Cycle C, so I will touch lightly upon the Lukan gospel as we move through the commentary.

In the Lukan version of the parable, a man entrusts each of three servants with an amount of money – actually there are ten servants, but in the end only three play a part in the last scene. Upon his return, the first two have worked with the capital and greatly increased it. Attention focuses on the third, who has acted with caution not to lose what was entrusted to him and is able to return it whole to the master. It is unclear how this last servant was perceived by the original hearers of the parable. There is good evidence that they would have considered burying the money a responsible act, but not necessarily keeping it stored in a handkerchief. The third servant in the Lukan version would be seen to have acted irresponsibly and is thus merely lucky to still have it at the master’s return. When the Lukan third servant is challenged as to why he has not increased the money entrusted to him, he responds with a characterization of the master as a harsh and unjust man who inspires only fear and caution. 

This perhaps gives the original hearers a bit of a pause. On the one hand, the hearers have just seen proof of the master’s generosity to the first two servants. On the other hand, the story has led them to be sympathetic to the action of the one-talent man in carefully hiding the money. To his (and the hearers’) surprise, the one-talent man is condemned for fearful inactivity, and his money is given to the first servant, who already has ten talents. The hearers must decide which characterization of the master to accept. The parable has led them in both directions, and it creates a dilemma rather than resolving one.

The careful listener should now be asking whether the original grant of money was entrusted to the servants to manage or was it given to them as their own. Perhaps only the third servant continues to regard the money as his master’s. If true, then the whole parable must be understood in terms of grace and the response to it, rather than stewardship of property that remains another’s.

Luke has positioned this parable between the story of Zacchaeus and Jesus’ entry into Jerusalem. Matthew has positioned the parable (with different details) between his “Little Apocalypse” and a scene of the final judgment. It may well point to a different intention and understanding. But then parables always have such leeway. As mentioned above, “readiness” seems to be the point of Matthew’s use of the parable – but then, we shall see.

Matthew’s Thought. A comparison with other Matthean parables is useful. (1) In 18:23–35, a servant is entrusted with the great wealth of another, and an accounting is called for (only place in the NT this expression is used). The servant is forgiven a fabulous debt incurred by his mismanagement of his master’s money. In our parable, a servant is condemned, although he had lost nothing of his master’s money. (2) In both parables the servant is called “wicked.” (3) But, earlier, the judgment is a matter of actively and profligately abusing his authority, while in the later parable the “wicked” servant is cautiously circumspect. (4) the final judgments in each case are severe: “Then in anger his master handed him over to the torturers until he should pay back the whole debt.” (18:34) – and – “And throw this useless servant into the darkness outside, where there will be wailing and grinding of teeth.” (25:30). It is worth noting that the differences are in what lead to judgment: abuse and profligate waste, as well as, lack of action.

Such contrasts in Matthew’s pictures of the judgment and the ultimate judge serve to guard the reader from too readily objectifying the meanings presented allegorically and to frustrate our efforts to summarize the way God works into neat coherent systems. The pictures point beyond themselves and resist systematization, while still speaking of the reality of judgment and the necessity for decision and responsible action – in other words, “readiness.”

Keep in mind that in our parable, the servants are not surprised at their master’s coming, so “readiness” is more attuned to whether the servants will be dependable in the use of the resources. We should note that the master entrusted his resources to the servants “to each according to his ability” (25:15). The third one received only one talent, likely indicating that the master understands that he has less ability than the others. The master does not overburden the third servant who nonetheless fails – not in any loss of money, but in returning it without increase. It was not that he did something wrong—he simply did nothing. This helps focus the parable, narrowing the focus to maximizing opportunities, not wasting them. To be “ready” for the master’s return means to use the intervening time to “maximum gain”; it is again about continuing life and work rather than about calculating the date and being alert for his actual arrival.


Image credit: The Parable of the Talents by Willem de Porter, 17th century, National Gallery of Prague, PD-US

More Background

This coming Sunday is the 33rd Sunday in Ordinary Time. Our gospel is the Parable of the Talents. Over the years I have added additional background materials. As a result, this week there will be days with more than one post – such as today! I hope you find it interesting and not too arcane.

Parallels. This parable has parallels in Mark and Luke. The version in Mark (13:34 ff) sticks to the basic storyline but lacks the detail present in Matthew’s version. The version in Luke (19:11-27) is slightly more rich in details than Matthew, but there are differences: an explicit explanatory introduction (Luke 19:11), the added motif of the journey “to receive kingship,” rebellious subjects, and their punishment (Luke 19:14, 27).  Moreover, the details of the story in Luke differ significantly: ten slaves, each given the same amount although much smaller sums of money (mina vs. talent) than in Matthew.  Also there is the resulting authority over cities as the reward for good trading.

The essential pattern of the story of trading in the master’s absence is the same, with three servants singled out, similar commendation of the successful slaves, the same excuses by the third servant and the same response from the master, the one talent/mina given to the servant with ten, and even the same apparently editorial comment in Luke 19:26 as in Matt 25:29: “ For to everyone who has, more will be given and he will grow rich; but from the one who has not, even what he has will be taken away.”.

There is one version of the parable that appears in the apocryphal “Gospel of the Nazarenes” (likely written late 2nd century in Alexandria). There one servant multiplies the capital, one hides it, and one squanders it with harlots and flute girls. The first is rewarded, the second rebuked, the third cast into prison. This version focuses on the end judgment with little attention to preparedness or vigilance.

The preceding parables have been about readiness, and this one is particularly about faithful stewardship which readiness produces. The third in the series of parables about being ready returns to a setting similar to that of the first, a master dealing with his servants. But this time there is a more specific focus on their commercial responsibility in their master’s absence. Each is left with a very large sum of money, with no instructions on what to do with it, and the story turns on their different ways of exercising this responsibility. There is again a division between good and bad, between success and failure. Yet the “failure” of the last servant consists not in any loss of money, but in returning it without increase. It was not that he did something wrong—he simply did nothing. This is, then, apparently, a parable about maximizing opportunities, not wasting them. To be “ready” for the master’s return means to use the intervening time to maximum gain; it is again about continuing life and work rather than about calculating the date and being alert for his actual arrival. This third parable is thus essentially making the same point about readiness as the two preceding ones (Mt 24:45-51 and Mt 25:1-13).

Eschatological Application. “Eschatology” refers to the part of theology concerned with death, judgment, and the final destiny of the soul and of humankind. With the parable set between Matthew’s “little apocalypse” and verses regarding the judgment upon the nations, one is rightly prepared to be concerned with things eschatological. This very setting affects the way the parable is told. The repeated invitation, “Come, share your master’s joy” (vv. 21, 23), sounds more like the language of heaven than of commerce; and the ultimate fate of the unsuccessful servant is described in v. 30 in the eschatological terms which have become familiar from other judgment sayings and parables (8:12; 22:13; cf. 13:42, 50; 24:51).

As an aside, the excellent scripture scholar N. T. Wright [Victory 632–639] argues that the parable is not about Jesus’ parousia (2nd coming) but about the OT hope of “YHWH’s return to Zion,” symbolized and embodied in Jesus’ own coming to Jerusalem. Wright argues for a “realized eschatology” that is completely fulfilled in the person of Jesus. He has a point although this proposal fits much better with the introduction in Luke 19:11 than with the Matthean context, unless one is prepared to argue, as Wright does, that there is no idea of Jesus’ parousia anywhere in this discourse. It should be noted that Wright is of the considered view there is no idea of the parousia anywhere in the gospels.


Image credit: The Parable of the Talents by Willem de Porter, 17th century, National Gallery of Prague, PD-US

Context and Background

This coming Sunday is the 33rd Sunday in Ordinary Time, Lectionary Cycle A. Our gospel is the Parable of the Talents. The gospel readings for the 29th through 31st Sundays in Lectionary Cycle A all describe a series of confrontations between Jesus and religious authorities of Jerusalem, namely the scribes and Pharisees (Matthew 22 and 23). While not a part of Ordinary Time readings, Chapter 24 continues this theme of imminent destruction and coming tribulation (Mt 24:1-28). It is at this point that we turn the page to Matthew 25. It is here in Matthew 25 that we will finish the final three Sundays of this cycle of Ordinary Time:

  • 32nd Sunday: The Wise and Foolish Maidens (vv. 1-13)
  • 33rd Sunday: The Parable of the Talents (also “of the Three Servants; vv. 14-30) ~ our gospel
  • Christ the King: The Great Judgment (vv. 31-46)

What is the Focus? One question which can be asked of the gospels for the 32nd and 33rd Sundays is about the focus. Some scholars hold that it concentrates on the judgment scenes which conclude the parables.  Others hold that its focus is rightly a theme of ‘being ready’, which continues the theme that dominated the preceding parable and is still at the center of our gospel parable for this week. One scholar (Lambrecht) offers that this whole section should be labeled as an “Exhortation to Vigilance” for its portrayal of a ‘coming’ and its consequences for those who should have been preparing for it.

The parable of the talents takes up the question which that of the bridesmaids left unanswered: what is ‘readiness’? While the bridesmaids might be said to be passively waiting, here in this parable, it is not a matter of passively ‘waiting’, but of responsible activity, producing results which the coming ‘master’ can see and approve. The period of waiting was not intended to be an empty, meaningless ‘delay’, but a period of opportunity to put to good use the ‘talents’ entrusted to his ‘slaves’. It is a theme that is clearly present in the account of the Faithful and Unfaithful Servant.

Talents. The Greek word used in the parable, talanton, has no metaphorical meaning. It is simply a weight measure of a precious metal such as gold or silver. Our English use of the word to mean an aptitude or ability really only dates to the late 13th century when it appeared in a metaphorical musing on the parable. Prior to that time, even the middle French and Latin equivalent to the Greek talanton meant “weight.” We point this out to remind us all that before one moves to a metaphorical sense of Scripture, one should consider the literal sense.


Image credit: The Parable of the Talents by Willem de Porter, 17th century, National Gallery of Prague, PD-US

Being Known and a Final Thought

This coming Sunday is the 32nd Sunday of Ordinary Time. Our gospel is the parable of the Ten Virgins. 11 Afterwards the other virgins came and said, ‘Lord, Lord, open the door for us!’ 12 But he said in reply, ‘Amen, I say to you, I do not know you.’

Such is the plaintive cry of those who thought they ought to be included. With the emphatic formula, “Amen, Amen” the following words have the force of a judicial verdict. “”I do not know you.” This dramatic verse carries a profound and symbolic meaning within the context of the parable and possibly underscores several important spiritual concepts:

Spiritual Preparedness: The parable of the ten virgins is a story of readiness for the coming of the Kingdom of Heaven. The five wise virgins represent those who are spiritually prepared and vigilant, while the five foolish virgins represent those who are unprepared and lack spiritual readiness. The statement by the bridegroom highlights the consequences of being unprepared. In the spiritual context, not being “known” by the bridegroom means that one is not recognized as part of the prepared and faithful community.

Personal Relationship: The phrase “I do not know you” also reflects the idea of a personal relationship with God. In the Christian tradition, knowing God is often associated with having a close and intimate relationship with Him through faith and obedience. The unprepared virgins are symbolically shown as lacking this personal relationship with the bridegroom be it through faith or obedience to the Word of God.

Exclusivity of the Kingdom: The statement conveys the exclusivity of the Kingdom of Heaven. In other words, only those who are spiritually prepared, who have a genuine relationship with God, and who have lived in accordance with His teachings will be welcomed into the Kingdom.

Finality: The statement carries a sense of finality and judgment. In the context of the parable, once the door to the wedding feast is shut, it is too late for the foolish virgins to gain entry. This emphasizes the idea that there will be a point of no return in the eschatological events, and individuals must be prepared beforehand.

It is striking that the comparatively trivial lapse of a failure to be provided with oil has come to symbolize an ultimately false relationship; they are not part of Jesus’ true family (12:50).

A Final Thought  Eugene Boring [1994, 451] offers:

Right at the beginning of the parable of the ten bridesmaids, Jesus tells us that five of them were foolish, and five were wise. The reason why he tells us this from the onset is that we cannot tell this just by looking at them. All ten have come to the wedding; all ten have their lamps aglow with expectation, all ten, presumably, have on their bridesmaid gowns. We would never guess from appearances that half were wise and half foolish.

No, it is not the looks, the lamps, or the long dresses that sets the wise apart from the foolish – it’s the readiness. Five of the bridesmaids are ready for the groom to be delayed, but the other five are not. The wise have enough oil for the wedding to start whenever the groom arrives; the foolish only have enough oil for their own timetable. Five are prepared and ready, even for a delay; five are not.

Readiness in Matthew is, of course, living the life of the kingdom, living the quality of life described in the Sermon on the Mount. Many can do this for a short while; but when the kingdom is delayed, the problems arise. Being a peacemaker for a day is not as demanding as being a peacemaker year after year when hostility breaks out again and again, and the bridegroom is delayed. Being merciful for an evening can be pleasant; being merciful for a lifetime, when the groom is delayed, requires preparedness.

At the beginning of the life of faith, you cannot really tell the followers of Jesus apart. They all have lamps; they are all excited about the wedding; they all know who to sing, “Lord, Lord.” Deep into the night, when we spot some persons attempting in vain to fan a dying flame to life, we begin to distinguish wisdom from foolishness.


Image credit: Greek Fresco, “Bridal Chamber”, iconreader.wordpress.com, CC-BY

Wise and Foolish: being prepared

This coming Sunday is the 32nd Sunday of Ordinary Time. Our gospel is the parable of the Ten Virgins. At the center of the parable are the “ten virgins who took their lamps and went out to meet the bridegroom. Five of them were foolish and five were wise”  Matthew has already used this doublet in the Sermon on the Mount. At the opening of the Sermon, Matthew 5:13, “You are the salt of the earth. But if salt loses its taste, with what can it be seasoned? It is no longer good for anything but to be thrown out and trampled underfoot.” The expression loses its taste, literally “becomes foolish.”

And again at the closing of the Sermon in the parable of the two house-builders (Mt 7:24-27): “Everyone who listens to these words of mine and acts on them will be like a wise man who built his house on rock. The rain fell, the floods came, and the winds blew and buffeted the house. But it did not collapse; it had been set solidly on rock. And everyone who listens to these words of mine but does not act on them will be like a fool who built his house on sand. The rain fell, the floods came, and the winds blew and buffeted the house. And it collapsed and was completely ruined.” (Mt 5:24-27)

The wisdom/foolishness is centered on having gathered sufficient oil for the task at hand – being vigilant and prepared for the arrival of the bridegroom: The foolish ones, when taking their lamps, brought no oil with them, but the wise brought flasks of oil with their lamps. (Mt 25:3-4) The portable torches for outdoor use (the word is not the same as that used for a standing domestic lamp in 5:15 and 6:22) would be bundles of cloth mounted on a carrying stick and soaked with oil. The jars held the oil into which the torch was dipped before lighting. A torch without a jar of oil is comparable to a modern flashlight without a battery.

5 Since the bridegroom was long delayed, they all became drowsy and fell asleep.  6 At midnight, there was a cry, ‘Behold, the bridegroom! Come out to meet him!’ 7 Then all those virgins got up and trimmed their lamps. (Mt 25:5-7)

The parable gives the impression that the young women thought they knew when the bridegroom would arrive, and had not reckoned on the delay. A torchlight procession would of course be after dark, but might be expected to be before the middle of the night. The parable thus illustrates both the fact that the time of the parousia is unknown, and may not be as soon as people might expect, and also its sudden, unexpected nature when it does come, the middle of the night being the time when people are at their least alert. By the time Matthew wrote his gospel both these factors might be expected to be in play, with some Christians anxious over the delay of the “imminent” parousia, and others complacent after years of unfulfilled prediction. But the story does not develop as the call to vigilance in the earlier Matthean parables might have led us to expect: the wise ones did not stay awake while their companions slept. All were equally disappointed by the delay, all fell asleep, and all were equally taken by surprise by the eventual shout.

7 Then all those virgins got up and trimmed their lamps. 8 The foolish ones said to the wise, ‘Give us some of your oil, for our lamps are going out.’ 9 But the wise ones replied, ‘No, for there may not be enough for us and you. Go instead to the merchants and buy some for yourselves.’ 

We do not know whether the torches had been lit when the girls first set out, but if so they would not have stayed burning while they slept; even a well-soaked torch would not burn for much more than a quarter of an hour. So the wise ones would resoak and light their torches, while the attempts of the foolish ones were of course futile: “for our lamps are going out” suggests that as they lighted the torches they immediately went out again, having no more oil to keep them burning. The response of the wise ones to their natural request for a share of the oil may sound selfish, and perhaps in a real life situation they might have been willing to share—though if their supply too was limited, to keep it for themselves ensured that at least some torches would stay alight. But in a parable things do not always happen according to real life, and the hard-nosed realism of the wise girls invites the reader to reflect that spiritual preparedness is not something that others can provide for you: each needs their own oil.

One might note that the idea a merchant would be open in the middle of the night is not realistic, but it is a parable, and such an idea serves a rich irony to the reader in the vain attempt to prepare when it is already too late.

10 While they went off to buy it, the bridegroom came and those who were ready went into the wedding feast with him. Then the door was locked. 

When the bridegroom arrives, the feast begins. As in other celebrations depicting the blessings of the kingdom of heaven (8:11–12 and 22:1–13). Only those who are prepared will enjoy the celebration.

One odd element, at least for real life, is the closing of the door, which seems out of place in the open hospitality and conviviality of a village wedding; late arrival is not normally an issue in oriental society, certainly not penalized in such a dramatic fashion. But then this is a parable which like so many of the other parables, a story of insiders and outsiders, of the saved and the lost, and the closing of the door symbolizes that final division at the last judgment – which is clearly a theme as one moves through Mt 25.


Image credit: Greek Fresco, “Bridal Chamber”, iconreader.wordpress.com, CC-BY

Lacking Oil

This coming Sunday is the 32nd Sunday of Ordinary Time. Our gospel is the parable of the Ten Virgins. It was not that five slept and five stayed awake: v. 5 says explicitly that they all slept and all had to be awakened by the midnight shout. The problem goes back to the preparations they had made before going to sleep. At the core of the problem is that they lacked oil for their lamps. While the parable itself offers no allegorical identification for the oil, we do know that oil is a rich and multifaceted symbol in both the Old and New Testaments. Its symbolic use carries various meanings and significance in different contexts. Here are some of the key ways in which oil is symbolically used in both the Old and New Testaments:

  • Anointing and Consecration: Oil was often used to anoint and consecrate individuals for specific roles and purposes. Kings, priests, and prophets were anointed with oil as a sign of God’s chosen and set-apart status. For example, David was anointed with oil by the prophet Samuel before becoming king (1 Samuel 16:13).
  • Healing and Restoration: Oil was used for medicinal purposes and symbolized healing and restoration. In the famous “Good Samaritan” parable, the Samaritan poured oil and wine on the wounds of the injured man to help heal and soothe his injuries (Luke 10:34).
  • Joy and Celebration: Oil was often used as part of festive occasions and celebrations. It was associated with joy, abundance, and blessings. In the psalms, the anointing of the head with oil is linked to the overflowing cup of God’s goodness (Psalm 23:5).
  • Sacrifice and Atonement: In some sacrificial rituals, oil was used as an offering to God. It symbolized consecration and reconciliation with God. It was also a component of the anointing oil used in the tabernacle and temple rituals (Exodus 30:22-33).
  • Anointing of Jesus: In the New Testament, the anointing of Jesus’ head or feet with oil is a symbol of reverence and recognition of His identity as the Messiah. The woman who anointed Jesus’ feet with expensive perfume in Luke 7:36-50 demonstrated deep love and devotion.
  • Healing and Miracles: In the ministry of Jesus and the early Christian Church, oil was used in conjunction with healing and miracles. In the book of James, anointing with oil is associated with prayer for the sick (James 5:14-15).
  • Illumination and Guidance: Oil lamps were common sources of light in the ancient world. Oil symbolizes illumination, guidance, and the presence of God’s Word. The psalmist describes God’s Word as a lamp to one’s feet and a light to one’s path (Psalm 119:105).

Certainly the last example is one that pertains to this parable in the literal sense. One might well argue that to have a full measure of oil in the allegorical sense is to have let the light of Christ illuminate, guide and help you prepare for this life and the next. The preceding and following parables both indicate an understanding of what it means to be ready.  But the point is simply that readiness, whatever form it takes, is not something that can be achieved by a last-minute adjustment. It depends on long-term provision, and if that has been made, the wise disciple can sleep secure in the knowledge that everything is ready.

All that being said, one is then struck with the oddness of v.13 – “Therefore, stay awake, for you know neither the day nor the hour.”  Its oddness is that “stayinging awake” is precisely what none of the ten girls did, and the wise ones did not suffer because of their dozing.  It is almost as though it is an added on as it virtually repeats Mt 24:42, where it precedes a parable which was about staying awake. Nonetheless both Matthew and Luke use this expression with a sense of vigilance and readiness. With that language already in play with Matthew, one might simply offer vigilance and readiness, necessarily encompass preparedness, which is a concern of the parable.


Image credit: Greek Fresco, “Bridal Chamber”, iconreader.wordpress.com, CC-BY

Parthenos and a locked door

This coming Sunday is the 32nd Sunday of Ordinary Time. Our gospel is the parable of the Ten Virgins. “…the kingdom of heaven will be like ten virgins who took their lamps and went out to meet the bridegroom.” (Mt 25:1) As best we can know the scene is part of the procession returning to the bridegroom’s home. This story mentions only two parties, the bridegroom and the ten girls. The precise role of the young women in the ceremonies is not clear but most scholars assume that  Hellenistic-Roman marriage customs also apply in Jewish circles at the time, and thus the young women are servants from the bridegroom’s house, awaiting the return of the bridegroom with his bride.

The young women are described with the Greek term for “virgins” (parthenos). Parthenos occurs 15 times in the NT: 6 times in 1 Corinthians, 4 times in Matthew, twice in Luke, and once each in Acts, 2 Corinthians, and Revelation.

Occasionally parthenos refers just to a young woman of marriageable age. This is the case, e.g., in the parable of the ten parthenos (Matt 25:1, 7, 11), the young women who are waiting for the bridegroom and are as yet unmarried. The point of the parable does not depend on their “virginity” in the strict sense. Similarly, parthenos’ use seems unrelated to the point of verse. For example, in Acts 21:9 – “He had four virgin daughters gifted with prophecy.” The four daughters of Philip are described as “young” and  parthenos. Here the reference is likely that they had reached a marriageable age and presumably also virgins – but the description is apart from the main point of the verse: prophetic gifts. So too, in Matthew’s use of parthenos. The point of the pericope is about preparedness.  Perhaps “young” is a more germain aspect.  (Note: In Matthew and Luke, in reference to Mary, the intended meaning is “virgin” in the strict sense. St. Paul’s use is mixed) [Horst Robert Balz and Gerhard Schneider. Exegetical dictionary of the New Testament 1990, Vol 3:39]

The story tells us that their role included escorting the bridegroom in a torchlight procession to his house, but that they were not present at whatever part of the ceremonies immediately preceded this procession. There is an unexpected delay. The reasons for which do not matter. All that matters is the delay, and the effect it had on the readiness of the young women when the time for their part in the ceremonies eventually arrived. Their role seems to have been to be a formal escort into the wedding feast at the bridegroom’s house, the high point of the celebration.

Entering the celebration with the bride and bridegroom is the turning point of the parable. To miss that is to miss everything:  “the bridegroom came and those who were ready went into the wedding feast with him. Then the door was locked.” (Mt 25:10) The emphatic closure and locking of the door harkens to a scene of eschatological (end-times) judgment.

At this point it is good to remember an earlier Matthean scene when Jesus is teaching the followers what it means to be true disciples: “Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only the one who does the will of my Father in heaven. Many will say to me on that day,o ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name? Did we not drive out demons in your name? Did we not do mighty deeds in your name?’ Then I will declare to them solemnly, ‘I never knew you. Depart from me, you evildoers.’ (Mt 7:21-23)

The earlier teaching is echoed here in the parable when the foolish young women address the bridegroom as “Lord, Lord, open the door for us” and his response is, “I do not know you.” Clearly the bridegroom knew his own wedding party, but that is not the point of the parable. The question that begs an answer is why then did the five foolish ones miss the feast?


Image credit: Greek Fresco, “Bridal Chamber”, iconreader.wordpress.com, CC-BY