Free Speech and the First Reading

Here in the United States, free speech is protected by an absolutist constitutional First Amendment. We might find someone’s speech repugnant, etc. and wish it would “go away” but as much as it might rub us the wrong way we acknowledge free speech is a fundamental right unless it crosses the line in the narrow categories of expression that cause direct, immediate harm, illegal acts, or fraud.

In a 1974 Yale Law Journal, law professor William L. Cary popularized an economic and legal concept originally coined by U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis. Cary coined the phrase: “racing to the bottom.” Wikipedia describes the expression’s popular use: “Over the late 20th and early 2011s, the phrase crossed over from academic economics and corporate law into the sociopolitical lexicon. In discussions of public decorum, it applies the same structural logic: a negative feedback loop where competing entities (such as politicians, media outlets, or public figures) realize they can gain short-term attention or advantage by abandoning traditional standards, insulting rivals, and lowering the bar of civility. Because one side lowers their standards, the other feels compelled to match them to stay relevant, driving a collective descent into vulgarity or hostility.”

Not sure of the pathway in the Ohio race for Governor, but the recent ad by the Republican candidate’s campaign seems to have entered the race.  One can’t help considering that in the context of this morning’s first reading: “Brothers and sisters: Be kind to one another, compassionate, forgiving one another as God has forgiven you in Christ. Be imitators of God, as beloved children, and live in love as Christ loved us…” (Eph 4:32 – 5:1)

It is always good to check yourself. Are you following St. Paul’s advice, staying on the path of love, or are you straying afield and racing to the bottom.

How far

It has been my experience that people just beginning serious study of Sacred Scriptures follow a pattern: the Gospels/Acts, selected Old Testament books, and then the letters of St. Paul. One of the challenges in reading and understanding Paul is that you are often only listening to half of the conversation. Often Paul is responding to some news or correspondence he has received from the particular Christian community, e.g. Corinth and Galatia. This week’s first readings are mostly taken from the Letter to the Ephesians, a letter that lacks any personal greetings and seems, as some scholars offer, a “circular letter” meant to be received, copied and passed on to the next community. One is left to wonder if Paul is writing about a problem or whether the majestic chapters of Ephesians are meant to be an overarching message that emphasizes the unity in the church of Christ that has come about for both Jews and Gentiles within God’s household.

In the first reading today, Paul talks about “the mystery was made known to me by revelation.” He tells us the great mystery: the Gentiles would share in God’s promises. But wait a minute. Didn’t Isaiah already say that the nations would come to worship God? Didn’t God promise Abraham that all the families of the earth would be blessed through him? So what exactly was the mystery?

The surprise wasn’t simply that the Gentiles were invited but that they were no longer outsiders. “The Gentiles are coheirs [synklēronoma], members of the same Body [syssōma], and co-partners [symmetocha] in the promise in Christ Jesus through the gospel.”  The underlying Greek and its near alliteration drives the point home. They didn’t have to become someone else before they could belong to Christ. The middle word, syssōma, is especially striking. It is an unusual Greek formation, emphasizing membership in the very same body, not simply association between two communities. The emphasis isn’t merely that Gentiles may receive blessings from Israel’s God. They become equal participants in God’s promise through Christ.

Prophetic expectation was that the nations would come to Zion and worship Israel’s God. But the mystery revealed in Christ is that Jews and Gentiles are reconciled in Christ and together constitute one new humanity, sharing the same access to the Father through the Spirit. The prophets saw the nations coming to God. But they did not see the full shape of the Church as the one Body of Christ, constituted through his death and resurrection, in which Gentiles share fully in the promise without becoming Jews. All this is no longer some future event, but one that has already happened. The Church itself has become the visible expression of what God has accomplished. “So that the manifold wisdom of God might now be made known through the church to the principalities and authorities in the heavens.”

If God’s great mystery is that people once separated have become one in Christ, then the Church cannot proclaim that mystery while casually accepting divisions within its own life. We cannot celebrate being one Body while treating other members as though they don’t belong. And the challenge isn’t simply to be welcoming in a general sense. It is to recognize that the person whom I might regard as an outsider may already be someone Christ has made my brother or sister.

For generations, the prophets proclaimed that the nations would come to God. But in Christ, God did something more extraordinary than anyone had fully imagined. He didn’t simply invite the nations to come and visit. He made them family.

It is not that God had never hinted at what He intended to do, but that no one had yet seen just how far God’s promise would go.

And you have to wonder if God is done. How far might He go?


Image credit: “Christ at the home of Martha and Mary” | Charles de La Fosse | Private collection in a castle in Lorraine (France); Galerie Didier Chéreau, Paris | PD-US

The Armor of God

“Put on the armor of God so that you may be able to stand firm against the tactics of the Devil. For our struggle is not with flesh and blood but with the principalities, with the powers, with the world rulers of this present darkness, with the evil spirits in the heavens. Therefore, put on the armor of God, that you may be able to resist on the evil day and, having done everything, to hold your ground.” (Eph 6:11-13)

In today’s reading St. Paul uses the metaphor of the “armor of God.” I can remember the first time I heard the expression. It was spoken by someone who I thought, in general, was a bit dramatic about most things in life. Everything was a pitched battle between the forces of light and dark. While driving to a bible study at our country parish, a crow was spotted perched on a fence. “Look, it’s one of Satan’s demons!” Sometimes a crow is just a crow.

And then sometimes we have this reading on Halloween. Continue reading →

Letter to the Ephesians

Ephesians is the great Pauline letter about the church. It deals, however, not so much with a congregation in the city of Ephesus in Asia Minor as with the worldwide church, the head of which is Christ (Eph 4:15), the purpose of which is to be the instrument for making God’s plan of salvation known throughout the universe (Eph 3:9–10). Yet this ecclesiology is anchored in God’s saving love, shown in Jesus Christ (Eph 2:4–10), and the whole of redemption is rooted in the plan and accomplishment of the triune God (Eph 1:3–14). The language is often that of doxology (Eph 1:3–14) and prayer (cf. Eph 1:15–23; 3:14–19), indeed of liturgy and hymns (Eph 3:20–21; 5:14). Continue reading →