Laodicea

The first reading today is from the Book of Revelation and contains one of the seven letters to the Churches of Asia Minor. Part of the reading is often quoted in homilies and exhortations:

“To the angel of the Church in Laodicea, write this: … “I know your works; I know that you are neither cold nor hot. I wish you were either cold or hot. So, because you are lukewarm, neither hot nor cold, I will spit you out of my mouth. For you say, ‘I am rich and affluent and have no need of anything,’”

Laodicea is located in the Lycus Valley of modern-day Turkey. In its time it was positioned at the junction of major Roman trade routes connecting the Aegean coast to the interior of the area. Laodicea became one of the richest cities in the Roman province of Asia, renowned for its massive banking operations and gold reserves and hence you can understand the warning: “For you say, ‘I am rich and affluent and have no need of anything.” On a historical note: following a devastating earthquake around 60 AD, the citizens were so wealthy that they famously refused financial disaster relief from Emperor Nero, rebuilding the city entirely with their own funds.

But by locating on the junction of trade routes, it also located in a place where there was no natural water source unlike its neighbors Colossae, which enjoyed cold, refreshing mountain streams, and Hierapolis, famous for its hot, therapeutic thermal springs. Engineers piped water into Laodicea from miles away using stone aqueducts, causing the water to arrive lukewarm and heavily calcified with minerals, which often made visitors nauseated. And now you can understand the references to lukewarm and being spit from the mouth.

The warnings were clear: the citizens must fight against spiritual apathy and arrogant self-sufficiency unaware they were spiritually wretched, pitiful, poor, blind, and naked. But how did it all turn out?

Despite its harsh rebuke in Revelation, the Christian community in Laodicea survived and grew into a prominent church center of Byzantine Christianity. During the 4th century, the city hosted the influential Council of Laodicea, which issued 60 foundational canons that shaped church discipline, liturgy, and early debates over the biblical canon. In an interesting factoid, one canon banned clergy from entering taverns. But the Council also addressed more serious issues, specifically invocation of angels which was becoming an idolatry.

Located in a seismically active zone, Laodicea suffered severe earthquakes in the 5th and 7th centuries which led to several rebuilding efforts. Following a major 7th-century earthquake and later conflicts between the Byzantine Empire and Seljuk Turks in the 11th to 13th centuries, the city was gradually abandoned. Archeological excavation began in the 1830s but soon stopped only beginning again in the 1960s for a few years, and finally becoming an ongoing endeavor in 2002. The major church of the ancient city was discovered in 2010 using ground-penetrating radar. This early 4th-century basilica was built shortly after Emperor Constantine legalized Christianity and covered an entire city block.

Interestingly, Laodicea remained a titular see of the Roman Catholic Church even today, although the city is only an archaeological dig.  and the bishop’s seat has been vacant since 1968. The Catholic Church assigns titular sees, historic dioceses that no longer have a functioning local Catholic community, to preserve ancient Christian history and give bishops without a territorial diocese a canonical title. Titular sees are assigned to bishops serving in specialized roles where they do not govern their own independent diocese. Common examples include Vatican Officials such as Cardinals, archbishops, and bishops working in the Roman Curia (the central administration of the Holy See) and Papal Diplomats, i.e., Apostolic nuncios who represent the Pope to foreign governments and local churches around the world.


Image credit: Pexels via WordPress

…even more background

I promise – this is the last background post….This coming Sunday is the Solemnity of Christ the King. It is probably right to read “least brothers” as a description of disciples. But to draw that conclusion does not establish that the “sheep” are commended because their treatment of disciples reveals their positive attitude to Jesus himself. For the striking feature of this judgment scene is that both sheep and goats claim that they did not know that their actions were directed toward Jesus. Each is as surprised as the other to find their actions interpreted in that light. They have helped, or failed to help, not a Jesus recognized in his representatives, but a Jesus incognito. As far as they were concerned, it was simply an act of kindness to a fellow human being in need, not an expression of their attitude to Jesus. They seem closer to what some modern theologians call “anonymous Christians” than to openly declared supporters of Jesus himself.

So it does not seem to be possible to read this passage as expressing a “Pauline” doctrine of salvation through explicit faith in Jesus. A systematic theologian can devise a scheme whereby justification by grace through faith and judgment according to works are together parts of a greater whole, but Matthew is not writing systematic theology, and the present passage brings to its fullest expression his conviction that when the Son of Man comes he will “repay every person according to what they have done.” (16:27) This is the ultimate outworking of the Matthean motif of reward for those who have lived according to the will of God. And that will is here spelled out in terms of the way people have responded to the human needs of “least brothers.”

That being said, as Boring points out, this scene is absent the language of grace, faith, justification, or the forgiveness of sin. “What counts is whether one has acted with loving care for needy people. Such deeds are not a matter of ‘extra credit,’ but constitute the decisive criterion of judgment presupposed in all of vv.23-25, the ‘weightier matters of the Law’ of 23:32.” [Boring, 1994, 455]

Sovereignty. The debate about the criterion of judgment, however, theologically important as it is, should not be allowed to distract the reader from what is likely the main thrust of this passage: its portrayal of the ultimate sovereignty of the Son of Man as the universal judge. This theme has been developed in Matthew echoing the imagery of Dan 7:13–14. That passage provides the language for the scene in v. 31. The sovereign authority displayed in the judgment on the temple (24:30) now finds its eschatological counterpart in the judgment of all nations (v. 32). The focus on Jesus’ parousia in the preceding part of the discourse from 24:36 to 25:30 encourages the reader to associate this final judgment also with the parousia, as part of the same complex of eschatological motifs, but the scene itself is apparently set, like that of Dan 7:9–14, in the heavenly throne room, to which all people are summoned. There is no indication within this passage of the Son of Man coming to earth, unless that is assumed to be the meaning of the language of Dan 7:13, and we have already seen repeatedly that that is not how the Daniel vision is framed. The word parousia is not used here. The “coming” of v. 31 is no more specifically parousia language than it was in 24:30 and in all the other allusions to Daniel 7:13–14; it is the context rather than the wording of this passage which allows the reader to associate this judgment scene with the time of the parousia.  [France, 2007, 960]

Christological Titles

Eugene Boring points out that “a number of Christological titles important throughout Matthew converge in this scene.” Namely, “Son of Man” (v.31) who has “God as his father” (v.34). “King” which points to Messiah and Son of David – and also called “Lord.” He is the “messianic shepherd who cares for the sheep…and the judge who makes the final separation between sheep and goats.” [Boring, 1994, 455]


Image credit: Jacob Adriaensz Backer: Last Judgment (Matthew 25:31-33), National Museum in Warsaw, PD-US

OT References and More Background

This coming Sunday is the Solemnity of Christ the King. This passage from Matthew is particularly dense with OT references, uses language that has already appeared in earlier Matthean verses (thus already having a contextual meaning), and because of its eschatological setting, invites comparison with other sacred writers, especially, St. Paul. Hence a bit more “context” is needed, or better said, background.

Who is being judged? Our first impression is that this is a general judgment on all humanity. But coming at the end of Matthew’s gospel, one in which the meaning of discipleship has been an important message, we might be tempted to think that this judgment is one upon Christians and not necessarily a general judgment. Who are “all the nations” and who are “the least”? The usual interpretation understands “all the nations” as including all humanity, and “the least” as including people in distress of some kind. Therefore, at the final judgment all humanity is to be judged according to acts of kindness done to poor and suffering people.

But is this what Matthew and his community understood by the story? In Matthew’s Gospel, “nations” and “all the nations” usually refer to people other than Israel (see 4:15; 6:32; 10:5, 18; 12:18, 21; 20:19, 25; 21:43; 24:7, 9, 14; 28:19). In several passages (see 10:40–42; 18:6, 14), the “least brothers” seem to be Christians. If these terms have the same meaning in our gospel passage that they have elsewhere in the Gospel, “all the nations” are the Gentiles who have not explicitly accepted either Judaism or Christianity, and (in a strict interpretation) “the least” are Christians with whom the Gentiles have had some contact. According to this interpretation, the Gentiles will be judged according to acts of kindness done to Christians (see 10:40–42). [The Collegeville Bible Commentary, 1989, 898]

Can both be correct understandings? Certainly, but take note of the implications of Gentile (i.e., non-believers) being judged according to the acts of kindness done to Christians; and perhaps to non-Christians.

Either way, the theme of readiness comes to its climax in a vision of the judgment when, in fulfillment of the vision of Dan 7:13–14, the Son of Man is enthroned as judge over “all the nations,” and the great division will take place between those who are ready and those who are not ready. Where readiness was the primary theme (preparedness and active engagement), now we find a more explicit statement of the criterion of judgment, in the way people have treated “the least brothers of mine.”

How are they being judged? This passage has traditionally been an embarrassment especially to Protestant readers because it appears to say that one’s final destiny—and nothing could be much more final than “eternal punishment” or “eternal life,” v. 46—depends on acts of philanthropy, a most un-Pauline theology and one which sounds uncomfortably like Pelagianism. Some point out that the righteous don’t earn the kingdom, but they inherit it (v. 34) and that an inheritance is determined by the giver, not the receiver. The verb “to inherit” (kleronomeo) is used only three times in Matthew, with three different objects:

  • The meek inherit the earth (5:5)
  • Those who have left everything will inherit eternal life (19:29)
  • The righteous inherit the kingdom (25:34)

But there is one feature of this scene that has led probably the majority of recent interpreters to a different conclusion. The recipients of the acts of kindness are Jesus’ “least brothers,” and what is done to them is done to Him (v. 40). So, is the final judgment concerned not with response to human need in general, but to the need of disciples in particular, and thus indirectly with how people have responded to Jesus himself in the person of the least of my brothers? Has their response to disciples in need been their way of “acknowledging Jesus,” which was presented as the basis of judgment earlier in Mt 10:32–33: “Everyone who acknowledges me before others I will acknowledge before my heavenly Father. But whoever denies me before others, I will deny before my heavenly Father”? [France, 2007, 957-8]

While this addresses strict Pelagianism (pure works-righteousness) it does not address the Matthean emphasis on doing the will of God as the characteristic of God’s people. Some interpreters point out that this is Matthew and not Paul. Just as the preceding parables have told us that the master on his return will praise the slave who has been getting on with the job (24:46) and who has achieved good results (25:21, 23), this too is a call to good works which will be rewarded. The “For” which begins vv. 35 and 42 at least states that these acts of kindness are the evidence that the reward or punishment is deserved; but it may equally be read as stating the actual basis, or at least part of the basis, for the judgment given.

That interpretation has a firm foundation in the earlier language of this gospel, which has spoken of true disciples as Jesus’ brothers and sisters (12:46–50; cf. 28:10) and has used the phrase “these little ones” to denote members of the disciple community (10:42; 18:6, 10, 14—note in particular 18:6, “these little ones who believe in me”). In 18:5 we have been told that to welcome one such child in Jesus’ name is to welcome him, and that child becomes the basis for the phrase “these little ones” in the following verses.


Image credit: Jacob Adriaensz Backer: Last Judgment (Matthew 25:31-33), National Museum in Warsaw, PD-US